2 min read
The Complexity of Suitability in Family Mediation: Understanding Mediator Constraints

Family mediation plays a crucial role in helping individuals and families navigate complex issues and reach mutually agreeable solutions. However, there are instances where mediation may be deemed unsuitable, and the mediator may find themselves unable to provide a clear explanation for this determination. In the context of family mediation in England, where confidentiality is paramount and adherence to the Family Mediation Council (FMC) standards is crucial, it is essential to understand the complexities surrounding suitability assessments and the limitations faced by mediators.

Family mediators have limitations when it comes to signing Form A or the C100 as a mediator. These limitations stem from the strict rules of confidentiality and the need to maintain impartiality and neutrality throughout the mediation process. Mediators are often unable to provide a clear explanation for deeming mediation unsuitable or disclose specific reasons for a party's suitability or unsuitability for mediation. This is done to protect the privacy, trust, and confidentiality of all parties involved. 

Confidentiality and the FMC Standards

Confidentiality is a fundamental pillar of family mediation. The FMC standards place a strong emphasis on maintaining the privacy and trust of all parties involved. Mediators are bound by strict rules regarding the disclosure of information obtained during the mediation process. As such, they are unable to share specific details or provide evidence about a party's suitability or unsuitability for mediation.

Complexity of Suitability

Assessing suitability in family mediation is a complex and nuanced process. It involves considering various factors such as the nature of the dispute, the level of cooperation between parties, the presence of power imbalances, and the ability to freely communicate and negotiate. Mediators rely on their professional judgment, experience, and adherence to ethical guidelines to make these assessments.

Impartiality and Neutrality

Mediators are required to maintain impartiality and neutrality throughout the mediation process. This means that they must treat all parties equally, ensuring that no individual or perspective is favored over another. When faced with determining suitability, mediators must carefully evaluate whether their impartiality and neutrality can be maintained, taking into account the dynamics and circumstances of the case.

Power Imbalances and Coercion

In cases where significant power imbalances exist, mediation may not be suitable. Mediators must be aware of potential coercion or the risk of one party exerting undue influence over the other. Protecting vulnerable parties and ensuring their safety is of paramount importance. If a mediator identifies a situation where power imbalances may compromise the integrity of the mediation process, they may determine that mediation is not a viable option without explicitly disclosing the underlying reasons.

Informed Decision-Making

Family mediation relies on informed decision-making, where all parties have the necessary information to make choices that align with their best interests. If a mediator has concerns about one or more parties lacking the capacity to understand or participate effectively, they may deem the mediation unsuitable. However, disclosing such concerns could potentially breach confidentiality and undermine the trust necessary for successful mediation.


Family mediation in England operates under strict confidentiality rules and the guidance set forth by the Family Mediation Council. Mediators face the challenging task of assessing suitability while navigating complex dynamics and maintaining impartiality. The inability to provide explicit reasons for deeming mediation unsuitable is a necessary safeguard to protect the integrity of the process and respect the confidentiality of all parties involved.

As clients participating in family mediation, it is important to understand that the mediator's role is to facilitate communication, promote understanding, and guide the process. While the inability to disclose specific reasons for unsuitability may seem frustrating, it is a necessary protection to ensure fairness and maintain trust.

Ultimately, the goal of family mediation is to support parties in reaching mutually agreeable solutions. By respecting the confidentiality and expertise of the mediator, individuals can foster an environment conducive to open dialogue, understanding, and the exploration of alternative pathways to resolution.

* The email will not be published on the website.
Verification: a049c36190e2bc57